Monday, May 28, 2012

Lessons for my fictional children


The idea for this post struck me, I knew I had to write about it, but there is one fundamental discrepancy: I don’t want children of my own. So this post is more of a way for me to figure out my values. If I did raise children though, I would teach them....


  • Don’t ever let anyone outwork you.If someone claims they are intelligent, but only gets mediocre grades and blames it “not trying”, take them as the example of exactly what I do not want you to be. Useful intelligent people don’t waste their gifts and educational opportunities. It could be because I am american, but I strongly believe that hard-work is the key to success. At the end of the day its the person who does the work and not the brilliant mind that wins.
  • Take full responsibility for your actions.You are bound to mess up and make mistakes, hopefully none of them are life altering, but when you do mess up it is your responsibility to fix it. Do not blame your problems on other people or the circumstances, although they may have played a role, you had the ultimate choice, so own up to your shortcomings. Few things bother me more than people who are unwilling to admit to their mistakes.
  • Don’t judge.In your life, you will meet people of all different races, backgrounds, beliefs, and identities. I want you to treat them all the same. Each one is a human being and deserves equal respect from you. I am not saying that you have to like all them or be their best friends, but in the very least you must respect their humanity. If you do this, your hardest challenge will be accepting those who are intolerant. They will go against everything you believe in, and they will infuriate you, but you must remember that they are people too. Show them respect in return for their intolerance.
  • Stay firm in your beliefs, but keep an open mind.I encourage you to challenge your beliefs and change your mind, but do this with some skepticism. I want you to be strong in your conviction. Should you change your mind it should only be because someone else has presented you with a much better argument, or facts, not because “everyone else thinks/does this/that”. That being said, you should also be informed before you even choose and opinion. If you cannot defend your position there was no use taking it in the first place.
  • Always ask questions.Don’t ever blindly accept. You need to approach life with a little bit of skepticism even from the start. It’s hard to keep in mind that much of our life is social constructs that others blindly follow like sheep, and I never want you to be one of these sheep. This mindset may cause you some problems because you are somewhat slow to trust and sometimes avoid high-risk things, but it will help you in the long run. You won’t understand till later, but people are complex and until you have peeled back several layers of personality you don’t know who they really are.
  • Follow your heart, not tradition.There are traditions and expectations that society will but on you. There is an ideal of beauty for males and females, you are still expected to be heterosexual, and you will be told certain careers are acceptable. None of these things really matter; you could reject all of them and I wouldn’t care. Society’s rules don’t have to be your rules, as long as you are happy and comfortable with your choices, that’s all that matters.

This is how I would want my children perceived.

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

Guest Post: Heightism

The following is a guest post from my good friend Lindsay, who writes her own blog And How Do You Feel About That. She has written about the perception of height in our society.  Enjoy!

"Very few people want to admit how readily they judge others. I’ve discussed some of the subtle discrimination in our society, like the couching of racist remarks in “jokes” and descriptions, in my blog, which you can find here. But one lucky type of discrimination still enjoys a special place, still funny and socially acceptable. And it falls on the short guys.


In our society, we have many gendered expectations, and height comes into play as a masculine trait. Men who are taller are considered more assertive, powerful, and attractive, all because of certain genes that put them above the average height of 5’8’’. Connecting manliness with height in our society can affect people’s job credibility, their attractiveness to romantic partners, and their self-esteem.

These men have very few options when it comes to responding to others’ jabs at their height. If they laugh it off, they land a spot on the comedic roll, and risk being objectified by their height permanently. They become “cute,” “goofy,” not taken as seriously. If they respond seriously or try to defend themselves, they are told that it’s “just a joke,” not to take it to heart. Now they’re saddled with a Napoleon complex, so whenever they get touchy about jokes it’s their own fault, not the insensitivity of the joker.

That this prejudice can also be unconscious creates serious problems in the workplace, when men are considered less qualified for a position of leadership because of the lack of respect their stature demands. I believe if people are aware of the ramifications of this heightist approach, our society could make steps towards amending the situation.

If you are interested in pursuing the topic of heightism, The Social Complex has a wealth of information about the various impacts on society. Also, Sociological Images is a great place to find examples of prejudice and discrimination in our culture."

Saturday, April 14, 2012

Homosexuality and the Bible

I belong to a very liberal church. As such, we have been reading excerpts from Sex Texts from the Bible by Teresa J. Hornsby in my youth group. I found the section on homosexuality particularly interesting since the Bible has long been a tool to condemn homosexuality. Hornsby takes passage typically used to condemn homosexuality and puts the passages back into their historical context. Using this neo-historic approach, the potential interpretations of the scripture changes dramatically.

One of the most commonly cited passages to condemn homosexuality is Leviticus 20:13, "If a man lies with a male as with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination; they shall be put to death; their blood is upon them". Even Hornsby agrees that the message here is frank: men who have sex with other men shall be killed. What is more important she argues, is why the Israelites would have responded in such a way. The word "abomination" is translated from the Hebrew word tovah which means mixing or confusion or unlike things. In this case, the gender roles of man and woman are being mixed. Hornsby argues that they had these views of homosexuality because their culture depended on the idea of remaining separate and not "mixing", therefore any time when things were not in their proper category the Israelites saw it as dangerous to their culture and therefore repulsive (Hornsby 64). They respond with such extreme punishment because they see homosexuality as a threat to their existence since it is a form of "confusion" to them.

Whenever looking to the Bible for guidance, it is important to remember that it was not written for our culture and our modern problems. People chose what to include in the Bible and what to leave out. Many of the stories were also adopted to appease the social trends of the era when the Bible was first being put into writing because followers wanted Christianity to be more main stream.

Leviticus is the book of Jewish laws, few, if anyone, follows all the laws in Leviticus. Most Jews and Christians only follow a select few. I argue though that if we can arbitrarily choose which ones to follow and not follow, such as not keeping Kosher, we should not adopt these views on homosexuality.

Tuesday, April 3, 2012

KONY 2012

After having both my Twitter and Facebook accounts assaulted by the Kony 2012 video (if you have not seen it I am shocked, but here is the link), I felt compelled to write a blog post about it. I wouldn't consider myself an Invisible Children "hater" per-say, but I am definitely among their skeptics.

I'll start with some of the positives. The video has proven widely successful at raising awareness with over  86 million views since it's release less than one month ago. The organization set out to prove that young people can have an impact and change things, and so far they have proven that. They also helped add to the growing evidence that social media can be a power tool for social change. As a member of their target audience, I am comforted and emboldened by the fact that my voice can actually be heard. However, the organizations propaganda feeds into American misperceptions about Africa to gain support and attention.


The following is a quote from one of several open letters written to the CEO of Invisible Children, Jason Russell written by Penny Carothers , "By positioning yourself as the mouthpiece for this cause, you have denied the people of Uganda the opportunity to speak for themselves. You have depicted them as voiceless, hopeless, and at our mercy. Nothing could be further from the truth". The Uganda people are portrayed in this video as helpless, starving, and child-like, a stereotype that Americans are very comfortable with. I've written about this stereotype before in Simba doesn't live in Nairobi, and here again we see the same stereotype being used by an aid organization to try and garner support. It disgusts me a little bit that people with such big ideas would resort to such dehumanizing stereotypes to sell their ideas. Carothers goes on to say, "Jason, your video is slick and well produced, and it has garnered attention because it’s emotionally appealing and tragic. But it gives Americans the idea that they are the solution to the conflict, when they simply are not". That is what annoys me the most about this video. The message is: Americans must be the solution because Ugandans haven't fixed it yet.


The video also makes some fairly outrageous claims. They claim that no one cared about the issue and that the children were invisible before their organization came around, but that is complete specualtion. Also why are they invisible until recognized by a Western audience? Do they not truly exist until America cares? They also claim that the president could withdraw the military advisors from Uganda at any moment and then they would fail, so we have to keep pressuring the government. I am highly skeptical of this logic. First, I do not believe Obama would be so quick to pull out the 100 military advisors; he has nothing to gain from that. Second, the removal of those 100 military advisors would not ensure the failure of this campaign. The video seems to assert that without US military assistance the Ugandans cannot win. This patronizing view point frustrates me. 


In another open letter to Jason Russell by Amber Ha of the Acholi Times, she ends with this, "There is an Uganda saying that goes, 'The grass will always suffer when two elephants fight.' Isn't it time we let the grass grow?". 

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

US Military's Walk of Shame

Reputations are a precious and fragile thing, and as a teenager I am painful aware of this sometimes. However, the value of reputations does not change with age, even the most elite and sophisticated institutions depend on their reputations for legitimacy. Unfortunately the reputation of one of America's most prized institutions, our military, is under attack after the recent Quran burning and massacre in Afghanistan.

Protests resulting from the Quran burning.
The US military has not had a particularly stunning reputation, but the two most recent events in Afghanistan have sparked outrage and deadly protests from the Afghan people. The first event, the Quran burning seems to be an instance of cultural ignorance. NATO officers were destroying the Qurans because they came from a detention center and prisoners had been using them to pass coded notes to one another. It was not meant to disrespectful to the Muslim faith, but merely a security measure. The public however was outraged when they heard of the "Americans burning Qurans". Protesters swarmed to the NATO base trying to break down the gates. President Obama issued an apology, but many in the states, like this blog post argued the books were American property so we could destroy them however we wanted. Although I see the logic of the argument, I think this is just another example of cultural insensitivity. One could not burn an American flag in America to get rid of it without inciting rage from patriotic neighbors.

The aftermath of the massacre.
The details of the second event remain unclear. Several days ago a US soldier left a NATO base in the middle of the night, walked a mile into a local village and went on a killing spree resulting in the death or 16 people. Some were brutally murdered and others were gunned down, afterwards her burned the bodies. He then returned to the base and essential turned himself in as the story goes. The Taliban attacked an Afghan delegation visiting the site in retaliation.

Obviously both of these events have had a negative impact on the perception of the US military in Afghanistan and world wide. It is a shame given that there are 1,430,985 active US military personnel worldwide*, that the actions of 4 or 5 people create the global perception of our military. I hope President Obama will make a serious effort to promote the noble things the military does, but also still apologize for these events.


It's ironic how people think the same way. Many Americans generalize all Muslims as terrorists while there are millions of peaceful Muslims, and now Muslims in the Middle East are perceive the US military as cruel and barbaric while over a million of them are not. Another vicious circle. 

Sunday, February 26, 2012

A Feminist Look at the Causes of Depression

The general perception of depression is steadily improving. More and more people are beginning to recognize it as a treatable medical condition rather than a character flaw, but the stigma remains and the disease is still misunderstood. This is especially troubling for women, since according to the American Psychological Association they are twice as likely as men to develop depression and one in five women are expected to be diagnosed with depression (even though the APA also claims that 30-50% are misdiagnoses).

A combination of biological and social factors lead to increased depression rates in women, this article from the Mayo Clinic describes how things like pregnancy and menstruation can lead to depression in some women because of the major hormone changes that occur during each event. There are also social factors that contribute to women's propensity for depression. Women are more likely to have to care for children and balance work which causes stress, one of the major factors in developing depression. They are also more likely to be single parents. Women also typically make less money than men and people in tough economic situations are more prone to depression. But wait...there's more. Married women are more likely than single women to be depressed; despite social pressure for women to be married, it may not make them happy. Also, 90% of women with eating orders develop depression. Finally, women are more likely to be sexually assaulted or abused, and victims or any type of sexual abuse are very likely to develop depression. For a more in depth analysis of these causes, check out this article.

This is a vicious cycle, not only do traditional gender roles help lead to depression, but depression itself reinforces those same gender roles by making women seem emotional and physically weak. We need to make it clear that depression is not weakness, it is a treatable disease that our own culture has made women susceptible to. The words we use, whether we call it a disease or not have real consequences.

Friday, February 24, 2012

Shift in the Blog

As some of you may have noticed, the focus of my blog has shifted a little bit. At first I intended to write about appearances, but found that I was really focusing on our cultural perceptions and misperceptions. When I say perception I would also like to clarify that I am not using the psychology term, but rather the English word for "immediate and intuitive recognition". I feel as though it will better help me explore stereotypes and how different people perceive the world through different lenses.

Saturday, February 11, 2012

The Burkini Saga: A tale of research and bigotry

This blog post started out as a simple exploration of the cultural differences in modesty as exemplified by the striking contrast of the burkini vs the bikini, but the research for it took me on quite a journey.

In my research I read a blog post about a Muslim mother arguing with her daughter over what constitutes "modest" and how hard it is for the mother to combat the influences of Lady Gaga and Rihanna. It got really interesting in the comments section though, where ignorant and small-minded people posted things like, "So putting a bikini on your daughter is unthinkable, but strapping a bomb to her is ok?", and "Muslims hate all of God’s creation. That’s why they cover their women". I was shocked. I have never come across such blatant hatred and bigotry. I knew the article had been reposted on a right wing conservative site, but I had some faith that people would still be civil or at least informed...

So I created an account to post a reply to remind what I hesitate to call "fellow" conservatives that our country was founded on religious freedom, which extends to all beliefs even Muslims, and also to commend the user who reposted it as a fantastic insight into the struggles of assimilation in America. Within two minutes of posting I received an email saying my posting privileges had been revoked because, "This is not a liberal debating society. We are conservative activists dedicated to defending our rights, defending our constitution, defending our republic and defending our traditional American way of life". That's right, I'm not allowed to post anymore because they think I am...a liberal. Wow, that one got me laughing.

I then searched for the original blog post so that I could hopefully find a more informed discussion and less hatred, but to my utter disappointed I found more hatred. Instead I found a weird mixture of ultra-feminist and anti-Muslim sentiments. She felt that, "muslims are obsessed with sex, that's why they sexualize everything. that's why muslims think a woman who shows her hair is asking for it. muslim men are the most out of control men in the world".

Again, I was floored. I had no idea people actually thought like this. The ignorance hurts me on a deep and personal level. Where does all this hatred and anger come from? Why have millions of innocent people had to take the blame for the actions of a small group of extremists?

And to think, I stumbled upon all this hatred by simply searching "Burkini vs Bikini" on Google.

Sunday, February 5, 2012

The Mormon vs The Adulterer

I was inspired to write this post by this article from this Yahoo News article. For myself the choice seems clear if you were to vote solely on morality, you would choose the pious Mormon over a Roman Catholic adulterer, but for many Americans it is just as terrifying to consider a Mormon as it is an adulterer as president.

As made painfully clear by the results of the South Carolina primary, Romney does not have a strong base among the heavily Evangelical south. Taking a look at the chart below one can see Gingrich clearly had the advantage with Evangelicals while Romney clearly had the advantage with all other beliefs. This would suggest a strong correlation between a voter's religious background and their choice in GOP candidates.


Most Americans would sum up Mormonism with: polygamy, Utah, and BYU. Some do not believe they are Christians, in fact according to a Pew Research study 48% believe they are not or don't know, and 25% are less likely to for a candidate if they identify as a Mormon. They only groups who ranked lower in public opinions were Muslims and Atheists. It continues to amaze me though that Americans are less trusting of a pious man still on his first wife (despite polygamist stereotypes) than an adulterous man who married his mistress. Clearly one has a history of lying and dishonesty, but based solely on his religious background the American public perceive him as more trustworthy. 



There is a misperception about Mormons in this country, and it's proving to be a dangerous one. Obama is a beatable candidate this election cycle with many Americans finding his promises for change unfulfilled, but beating him will be no easy task. The GOP needs a strong candidate and no dissension among the party to win. It is highly unlikely that the heavily evangelical states will go blue, but many Republican still fear a third party run by Rick Perry which could very well take key votes from the GOP nominee. 

This simple ignorance of religious beliefs could potentially determine an election. 


Monday, January 2, 2012

Book Review: Public Enemies

Over winter break I had some time to read for fun, so I picked up Bryan Burrough's Public Enemies. A book that has since been turned into a major movie courtesy of Universal Pictures.


The book is a historical account of the crime wave of 1933-34 and the consequential rise of the FBI. Instead of a dry history text book feel, it reads like a novel jumping between different "characters", like John Dillinger and Machine Gun Kelly, to paint a picture of the simultaneous crime sprees. While chronicling the endeavors of America's most beloved criminals, it also documents the efforts made to apprehend them, which were laughable at best. It's long, 552 pages in total, but well worth it if you have any interest in the depression-era bank robbers, the FBI, or just American History.


What interested me the most, was how Burrough dealt with the public images of both the criminals and the crime fighters and contrasting them with reality. He spends much of the movie debunking myths about both  parties. For starters, there was nothing glamorous about organized crime in the 1930's. If these thugs were injured in a shoot out they couldn't seek medical help unless they knew a corrupt doctor, they frequently lived out of their cars, they had all types of STD's, and they were constantly on the run. More shocking is the how the FBI used to be viewed. Before it was the omnipresent federal crime fighting force it is today, it was basically a loose confederation of law school graduates who couldn't carry guns, make arrests without local police, or pursuit fugitives across state lines. One of Hoover's biggest struggles in the early days way establishing a menacing public-image for his new bureau (I laughed out loud several times at the horrific blunders of the FBI in it's early days).


John Dillinger proves an interesting case study in appearances. He was one of the few outlaws concerned with his public image; he had some delusional sense that he was a Robin Hood-like figure and that he was stealing from only the rich to benefit the poor. He always dressed nicely for robberies, treated his hostages with respect, and in one bout of theatrics actually gave a WPA worker back his money claiming he didn't want the people's money, but the banks. Dillinger's attentiveness to public image turned him into an American anti-hero. Many people supported him in his exploits against "the banks".

Wednesday, December 14, 2011

Eyebrows and hair, the key to the White House?

Ron Paul.
A friend of mine posted about fashion in politics on her blog, Applying Aesthetics, and I would like to address a similar issue. In less than a month, two articles have come up in my Google Reader from the NY Times regarding the appearances of the GOP candidates. Unlike the Applying Aesthetics post, both articles were about the men. In her post, Meghana discusses how women are prone to more scrutiny when it comes to how they dress and present themselves, but I think men are not immune to this scrutiny, especially in politics.


The first article that came up was about Ron Paul's eyebrows. Basically Ron Paul used fake eyebrows and in the hot studio lights of the presidential debate at Dartmouth, and the adhesive melted causing his fake eyebrow slipped creating the awkward appearance you can see to your right. A campaign spokesperson blamed Paul's allergies and denied that Ron Paul used fake eyebrows. I believe that was the best explanation, because everyone knows that allergies cause abrnomal growth of your eyebrows. What I am really curious about though is why Paul felt that he needed bushier eyebrows? This goes back to an earlier post I did about the advantages of appearance in elections. There must be data out there to support that voters favor candidates with fuller brows.


Mitt Romney.
The second article that I stumbled upon had to do with Mitt Romney's hair. The article describes how Romney's hair has come to represent him, "many [see] in his thick locks everything they love and loathe about the Republican candidate for the White House. (Commanding, reassuring, presidential, crow fans; too stiff, too slick, too perfect, complain critics)", claims the article. I always seem to underestimate the power of appearances. Literally Mitt Romney's hair could either be the key to the White House, or his demise. I thought back to the 2008 presidential election when Mike Huckabee took a crack at Romney by saying, "I want to be a president who reminds you of the guy you work with, not the guy who laid you off". This comment killed him. His image became one of a slick, greedy business man and not a trustworthy leader. None of these critiques center around actions or ideology, but rather appearances.

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

An Illustration of Military Spending.

This is a really striking graphic that illustrates our military expenditures that I found on the Bold Faith Type blog:

Cost of Military
From: MilitaryEducation.org

This graphic really puts things into perspective and makes me question what our priorities are as a nation.

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Catholics, Muslims, and American History



These images were first shown to me in a presentation by a University of Chicago professor, Alex Barna, regarding historical stereotypes and their relation to the current negative Islamic stereotypes. What struck me about the two images was that they were expressing the same negative stereotype using the same symbolism, but they were created roughly 100 years apart and address two totally different groups.

The first image depicts the Statue of Liberty with a Catholic clergyman as lady liberty and he stands on a bed of skulls. The second image depicts the Statue of Liberty shrouded in a burqa. Both warn of the impending invasion and take over of American values by a certain religious group. Having grown up in Chicago where almost all my neighbors are Catholic, anti-Catholicism in the United States is completely foreign to me, but there was a time in our history when Catholicism was seen as a threat, some argued we couldn't let Catholics into the government otherwise the Pope and Rome would eventually take control of the United States. This situation is eerily similar to the current movements in 13 states to ban the use of Sharia (Islamic law) in American courts. This article is somewhat biased, but it echoes my views. Fears about Sharia overtaking the American judicial system are completely unfounded. Sharia has many different interpretations and we can rest assured that no one will be sentenced to death by stoning for committing adultery in the United States, just as they are not in many Muslim countries.

I think it helps to think about our Islamophobia in the context of the anti-Catholicism that used to be rampant in the United States. A lot of our fear and misconceptions come for a general ignorance about Islam, but having much more exposure to Catholicism, it seems absurd to me that people were ever afraid of Catholic invasion. The Pope has yet take control of the United States and I'm sure he does not plan on it. It is harder to dismiss Catholics as all a bunch of fundamentalist crazies because we know more about them. Now if we take a step back, we see that history is repeating itself, but this time people are screaming about a Muslim invasion. In this blog post by Americans for an Informed Democracy, they do a fantastic job of discussing a variety of factors that have contributed to anti-Muslim sentiment as well as a brief history of it. It cites media, politicians, and the $40 million efforts of seven anti-Islam organizations as some of the major causes for our misunderstanding of the faith and its follwers.

We seem to always have a scapegoat. What we as a society claim are their faults don't change much, and neither do the threats they pose. We merely put a new outfit on the Statue of Liberty and warn our fellow Americans of the new impending invasion.

Sunday, November 27, 2011

Ignorance, a two-way street


After last week's post, I was really curious about the other side of this issue of stereotyping. People are more likely ignorant than informed, so I figured there had to be equally as inaccurate stereotypes regarding Americans. With the help of the same PBS article, and an assortment of political cartoons and blogs, I've chosen five common misconceptions to address that the rest of the world may hold about Americans.


  1. All Americans are rich. I feel as though this is a stereotype that people internalize, but with a little bit of thought they know it cannot logically be true. In fact, about 15% of Americans live in poverty, but that isn't the image we try and project to the world at large because that is not part of the "American dream". The TV shows we send abroad tend to focus more on the glamorous Hollywood side of things, which fuels more negative stereotypes.
  2. American women are promiscuous. Again, thank you Hollywood. This misconception seriously struck me though, because I think women are highly sexualized in American, there are many Americans who would say the same of European women. I know among my high school we would venture to make that judgement given our experiences with exchange students. European teens just seem so much more wild than us. They can drink and go to night clubs, while we have curfews until we are 18. I found it ironic that the country founded on Puritanical values now has a worldwide reputation for promiscuity.
  3. Americans are hypocrites. This stereotypes has validity in regards to the American government though. Obviously when we say we stand for freedom, but prop up dictators, we are labeled as hypocrites. Take for example our part in the 1953 Iranian coup d'etat, or even our involvement in Iraq can be seen with some hypocrisy. Although we do the same, projecting the actions of a government onto the population of a country, we all need to keep in mind that there are always people who opposed the government and no one idea or belief is shared by everyone in a country.
  4. Americans are lazy. This probably stems from the fact that one-third of Americans are obese, but I actually find this stereotype ironic because there is also the impression that Americans are always busy and always working. I keep playing with the idea of how you can be both lazy and incredibly over-scheduled?
  5. Americans are stupid. Well my appologies President Bush, but you didn't help us out much there. As an American who does not consider herself to be particularly stupid, this is one of the most offensive stereotypes to me. And here is a study, that is cited in the book Stupid White Men that made me feel better about my fellow Americans, turns out we are not alone in our stupidity...
89% of Canadians couldn't locate Iraq on a map, a higher "ignorance rate" than that of the United States.
81% of Canadians couldn't locate Israel on a map
5% of Canadians couldn't locate Canada on a map
90% of Britons couldn't locate Iraq on a map, again a worse figure than that of the US
21% of Britons couldn't locate the USA on a map
7% of Britons couldn't locate the England on a map
Swedes scored highest in the poll -- but even there 70% couldn't find Iraq


Sunday, November 13, 2011

How Americans Perceive the Middle East

In my English class we are learning about the Middle East and have taken a couple of days to address common misconceptions about the area. I was struck by how prevalent these misconceptions were and how I was tempted to accept some of them as fact. I will address the five that were the most striking to me. It's incredible how wrong our perceptions can be.

  1. All Arabs are Muslim and vice versa. Actually, most of the world's Muslims live in South East Asia in countries like Indonesia, Thailand and Malaysia. Click here for a map of the world's Muslim population. A minority of all Muslims are Arab, and not all Arabs are Muslim. There is a sizable Christian population in Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, and Lebanon. There are also Zoroastrians and Baha'i followers, although most of them are in Iran and Iranians are not Arab, they are Persian, which is a whole new misconception.
  2. Islam is a violent religion. "Islam" itself literally means "peace and submission to God", and every chapter of the Quran (the holy text of Islam) begins with, "In the name of God the Merciful and Compassionate". That was about all the convincing I needed to prove that the religion itself isn't violent, but instead a small minorities interpretation of the scripture is violent.
  3. Islam is oppressive towards women. Again we are confusing the culture of some Muslim societies with the religion of Islam. Just like there are conservative Americans who argue that women should "stay in the kitchen", there are conservative Muslims that believe in a domestic and restricted role for women. The difference is that in America, those who advocate fewer women's rights are not in power whereas the Taliban of Afghanistan, the Al Saud family of Saudi Arabia, and Islamic Republic Party in Iran are actually in power.
  4. The Middle East is one big sandy desert with lots of camels, populated by... men in turbans and long white robes... women in black with their faces covered... men waving long curved swords... harems with scantily clad women serving one man... husbands with four wives... rich oil sheikhs... and terrorists. I borrowed this from a PBS article because I believed it captured exactly how most Americans perceive the "Middle East". I don't think many people understand that the Sahara is in fact in Northern Africa, other than that the Arabian peninsula has deserts, but Iraq and Afghanistan are mountainous. Also turbans are not exclusive to Islam, Sikh men also wear turbans, and the harems and swords are reminiscent of Aladdin. Here again, most of Americans' knowledge of international culture comes from Disney movies.
  5. The veils are a sign of oppression, and all veils are burqas. First of all, there many different styles of veils ranging from just a head scarf or hijab, to the ultraconservative burqa which is extremely rare. Click here for an illustration of the different styles. Although we've adopted the word burqa, it is the most uncommon form of veiling. Even in Saudi Arabia, one of the most conservative Islamic states the burqa is uncommon. Secondly, the veils are not always a sign of oppression. Many women feel freer while wearing a veil because they are free from unwanted male attention; they feel less likely to be sexualized and viewed as an object while veiled. Some Muslim women also believe that women in the West are more oppressed for this same reason. Because we are so sexualized, they view that as just as much oppression, the same way we view the veil as oppression. These opposing view points really interested me because I had never imagine wearing a veil as freedom, but then I thought about how nice it would be to avoid unwanted attention...
Another great resource, click here to read Ruben Navarrette, a Muslim and Chicago native, debunk more myths and stereotypes about Islam and Muslims.


Sunday, October 30, 2011

I'm too pretty to...



This first tee shirt was featured in a blog post on the Beauty is Inside blog. I agreed with the post that wearing a shirt like this gives not only a highly-sexualized image of young girls, but it also makes them seem untrustworthy. The author found this shirt in the juniors department, which seems way too young to be flaunting your man-stealing prowess.
Upon reading this post, I was reminded of a similar controversy involving a girl’s tee shirts sold at JCPenney (click here to read about it). The following shirt was pulled after complaints poured into JCPenney.

What bothers me the most about all these tee shirts is that they reinforce sexism and sexualize girls at a very young age. Here words and appearance come together to teach young girls that math is only for ugly girls, and judging by the shirt design, we are also telling 7 or 8 year old girls to use their bodies and not their brains to get things done. As a high school senior in my second year of AP math classes, I find it offensive that we still market smart girls as ugly, weird, or nerdy. I am not an ultra-feminist, but these shirts are only a few examples of tons of sexist shirts on the market (click here for more examples).

Another thought that bothered me was that there are parents that let their children wear shirts with messages like this, or worse parents that buy these shirts for their kids. It’s disturbing when parents are actively involved in the premature sexualization of their own children. I’ll be honest, Toddler and Tiaras on TLC is one of my guilty pleasure shows, but beauty pageants are one of the most concrete examples of such a phenomenon. All of these subtle forms of sexism and sexualization of girls keep all females stuck in traditional gender roles.

Sunday, October 16, 2011

Simba doesn't live in Nairobi...

Consider for a moment the two attached pictures; which one best represents Africa?



My gut reaction was to chose the UNICEF advertisement with the despondent-looking children. But taking that stance infantilizes Africa. The second picture is one of Nairobi, Kenya, which although it may not be Chicago or New York is a functioning “modern” city that is also a part of Africa. I began to question what made me view Africa as a continent of starving orphans and not a place with a wide variety of people and problems? I came to the conclusion that American media coverage makes Africa appear helpless, childlike, and unable to solve its own problems.

To test this theory, I went to the New York Times and browsed through the articles of their Africa section. To my surprise, only one of the articles listed was about progress in Africa, and the rest were about either political unrest, violence, and natural disaster (I invited you to follow the link and see for yourself, that hardly any of the articles pertain to progress). To further support for my hypothesis, when I clicked on a link to read about Ugandan government officials stepping down amidst scandal, the following advertisement appeared at the top of the screen...





“Children are dying in East Africa”, and cue photo of a despondent child.

Now I don’t mean to dismiss the tragedies and suffering in Africa, but I would like to make clear that there are modern cities and capable adults in Africa. Until I was about twelve years old, I believed Africa was essentially The Lion King or The Jungle Book and I believe that kind of ignorance is dangerous. There has been a recent back lash against foreign aid in Africa and I would have to agree with it. The people of Africa are perfectly capable of solving their own problems, they only need capital and international support to do so.

Since most of our exposure to Africa is through ad campaigns such as UNICEF, Heifer, or the Red Cross, which want to illicit guilt through their photos, we are left with a distorted sense of Africa. For one we categorize the whole continent as one, like I have done throughout this post, even though there are innumerable tribes, languages, customs, and cultures throughout the continent. We also tend to cast Africa in victim narratives because of our media perception. We look to give handouts instead of advice, and want to intervene instead of assist.
Our media perception causes us to act a certain way in regards to Africa; so if we alter the media image or Africa, maybe we can shift people’s thinking as well?

I am curious to see how Africa appears to other people, feel free to comment!

Sunday, October 9, 2011

Hot or Not Elections


We would all like to believe that we live in a democracy populated by informed voters that cast their ballots based on a candidate’s credentials and perceived ability to lead, but how much of that perception has to do with ‘looking’ like a leader?

Appearance came into politics with force after The Great Debate between Nixon and Kennedy. It was the first presidential debate to be televised and Kennedy’s more youthful appearance gained him widespread support. More recently though political science researchers at MIT have discovered that there is somewhat of an international idea of what a good leader looks like. In the study they showed people in the United States and Canada pictures of election match ups in Mexico and Brazil. Participants were able to predict the election outcomes with 68% accuracy based on physical appearance alone. Even more surprising, the people from India and the United States chose the same candidate 75% of the time. Despite vastly different cultures and ideals of beauty, all four populations had similar ideas of what a good leader looks like.

In another study, researchers found that “low-information voters”, or people in the lowest quartile of political knowledge, were most heavily influenced by a candidates physical appearance. The effect was magnified by the amount of time the voter spent watching television. To me, this is very concerning. I never realized that the attack ads and incessant campaign ads actually worked, even after having interned on a senatorial campaign. I remember one of the staffers telling me, “Politics are nasty. We do what it takes to win, and trust me if people didn’t respond to nasty we wouldn’t use it”. The combined effect of low-information voters being swayed by appearances is roughly equal to the advantage of being an incumbent, researchers found. Again, this is a red flag. Human behavior isn’t going to change on it’s own, which makes me believe we need stricter campaign laws. If appearances alone can determine an election, something has to change.

I liken the dangers of looks being able to win elections, to the dangers of rhetoric alone winning elections. Charismatic and verbose leaders can sometimes be the most dangerous, igniting violence and spewing hatred with their words. There is danger in electing any sort of leader without first considering their qualifications. A country cannot be lead by a pretty face or great speeches; we need a doer.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Introductions

First impressions matter. Typically our first judgements of people come from the way they look, because no matter how many times we are told not to judge a book by its cover, we do. That’s why we even have a business sector devoted to marketing, and publishers that hire artists to create artwork for book covers. Scientists will argue that it's human nature to be attracted to more beautiful people and things, and people will argue that the world is shallow and narcissistic. Regardless of the angle you take, one fact remains: how things look is crucial.

We live in an image obsessed culture, where in many cases presentation means more than substance. I am experiencing my teenage years, developmental years heavily influence by appearance, in this image obsessed culture. I think this provides an interesting perspective, because my age group’s added attention to appearance has made me hypersensitive to it. The purpose of this blog will be to explore and discover new ways in which appearance impacts life.

Because I am a visual learner, I have always paid special attention to visual cues. I tend to notice how people dress, style their hair, and do their make up. I try not to judge them based on how they look, because my whole moral upbringing has been about getting to know people on the inside, but I cannot ignore the fact that looks matter. How a person decides to present themselves to the world has a lot to say about who they are. It is the ideas of visual cues and initial judgements that have captured my imagination and made me want to explore the varying roles of appearance in our lives. I want to know the science behind images, the psychology, and the larger cultural impacts of images. Appearances can influence behavior, reinforce stereotypes, and win elections. Looks matter, so it’s about time I tried to understand them.